Pages

Showing posts with label conservative. Show all posts
Showing posts with label conservative. Show all posts

Thursday, September 23, 2010

CRASH: Of Temerity, Timing and Trust

by swede

Seems I was just lamenting the absence of a GOP “manifesto” one might use to determine what “Republican Values” actually are in the bold new age of HopenChange. Well, fasten your seatbelt and pull out the barf bag from the seat pocket in front of you…we may hit turbulence.


In a stunning demonstration of brilliant timing, the Grand Old Party is finally rolling out its long awaited manifesto – immediately following the stunningly stupid Murkowski Meltdown – and that on the heels of the O’Donnell/Rove-rage. See, the thing you want to do, of course, is flagrantly demonstrate Washingtoon establishment business-as-usual-party-politics and a reality challenged disconnect with voters (not to mention common sense) – then immediately announce to them that you are the great Hope to Change all of that!



And what a piece of work it is! The new “Pledge to America” is already drawing rav(ing) reviews among pundits and sanitarium residents alike. Erickson at RedState dubs it “Perhaps the Most Ridiculous Thing to Come Out of Washington Since George McClellan” – a bizarre yet sadly appropriate analogy. The Hill glibly refers to it as the new “Contract with America” which coming from them one may assume is derogatory, but is inaccurate as this bears little resemblance to the former document.


It is, in my view, a partisan hacksheet of patriotic pablum, flowered up with quotes from everyone from Reagan to Kennedy to…Margaret Thatcher(?) Following a rather tedious attempt in the intro/forward to portray an epic historical document, the main text covers six promising looking, (if somewhat vague) conservative themes:

* A Plan to Create Jobs, End Economic Uncertainty, and Make America More Competitive
* A Plan to Stop Out-of-Control Spending and Reduce the Size of Government
* A Plan to Repeal and Replace the Government Takeover of Healthcare
* A Plan to Reform Congress and Restore Trust
* A Plan to Keep Our Nation Secure at Home and Abroad
* Checks and Balances




Sadly, it then fails to clearly define them and falls far short in proposing specific goals, means or timetables to achieve them. The hard reality is that assuming Republicans gain at least a House majority, it would be difficult to impossible to achieve significant headway on this agenda. Moreover, the Republican “leadership” lacks leadership dynamic – i.e. the gravitas, credibility, continuity and commitment to make it happen. And I can't help wondering if the GOP RINO/"moderate" faction really embraces this, or if it's window dressing to appease the Tea Party before the elections.


I suppose my obvious disillusionment with this revelation comes from a healthy dose of cynicism toward these people who were hardly fiscally conservative when they had the majority and the White House - and perhaps a naive hope that something might come along to clearly define, revive and unify conservative values in the GOP. Sorry, I just don't think this is it. Here you go--

Pledge to America

Wednesday, September 22, 2010

BURN: Senate GOP Just DOES NOT Get It...

Stupid, stupid, stupid...  There is no excuse for this.  The GOP, if they wanted to hack off conservatives, could not have done anything these days that would better do it.

In a rare triumph for Senate traditionalists in this anti-establishment year, Republicans Wednesday decided not to punish Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R., Alaska) by stripping her of a powerful committee post.
Senate Republicans, angered by Murkowski’s decision to run for re-election as a write-in candidate after losing the Republican primary, met behind closed doors to consider demoting her from her post as top Republican on the Energy and Natural Resources Committee, a prized perch for her resource-rich state.
But with the committee unlikely to conduct any further business this year and the act seen as largely symbolic, Republicans decided not to add insult to her injury at the hands of Joe Miller, the tea party-backed candidate who beat her in the primary.
“We all respect the system, and she still is a Republican senator,’’ said Sen. Orrin Hatch (R., Utah.) after the closed party caucus. “It’s just a matter of good taste. We decided to keep the status quo as long as she’s a senator.’’
The conservatives of America are not in the mood for doily dipping, patty-finger conduct.  Murky SHOULD have been hammered, losing her POWER and prestige in the Senate.  Instead, she stays as a defense of the "status quo".  If there is one thing that the GOP should understand, the status quo...business as usual...WILL NOT DO. 

Tuesday, September 21, 2010

CRASH: Manifesto Destiny

by swede

How does one provoke, enrage and/or gravely insult a conservative these days? You may try…

“You’re a racist homophobic Islamophobic nativist Neanderthal!” Nope. “You’re an idiot!” Nothing. “You’re insane?” Blink. “You’re a Nazi!” Please. “You’re a piece of s#!t!” Yaaaaawn. “Yo mama’s a ho!” Whatever. “You’re a RINO!” WTF are you talking about, punk? Who the %$&* are you? You’re a friggin Marxist compared to me so STFU and GFYS!



Ah, yes, the RINO card that reduces the recipient to a level somewhere between fungus and insect, negating any subsequent proposition he may make – effectively ending the dispute in favor of the one hurling said trendy epithet.

So…what exactly is a RINO,
I asks meself? Then I answers, typically, the answer boils down to, “I know one when I see one” (McCain of course being the Gold Standard) By definition, “Republican in Name Only” is a pejorative term refering to a member of the Republican Party whose views or actions are perceived as insufficiently conforming to “Republican Values.” Ah, but therein lies the rub. What are “Republican Values?” That used to mean “conservative values”, but in the post Bushian – New & Improved – One Big Size Tent Fits All GOP, it seems the values have gotten a bit – shall we say – scoza-fuzzy? So in a real sense, a true conservative would in fact be the RINO. And an Indy registered conservative like myself is not Republican of any flavor.


Not to worry, as of last February, “a group of more than 80 prominent conservative thinkers are set to unveil their version of a mission statement for the right.” But so far, nada. Ok, here we go, (Aug 30) “Boehner said the long-awaited Republican manifesto, detailing the policies the GOP would pursue if they win back control of the House or Senate, would be released shortly after lawmakers return to Washington.” Still nothing...

If they had the sense God gave a coconut, they might consider another “Republican Manifesto” crafted under very similar circumstances. Josiah Bailey was a freshman Senator for NC in 1930, and for the most part was unable to resist FDR’s New Deal monster from growing. But by his second term, the already anemic economy hit a recession, and partisan lines blurred. America had had it with the “Raw Deal”. Baily and a bi-partisan group worked on a Republican Manifesto, (in secret as FDR was well known for heavy handed retribution toward opponents) and rolled it out in 1937. You can’t tell me this, with a few tweaks, isn’t exactly what we need. Now.


1. Immediate revision of taxes on capital gains and undistributed profits in order to free investment funds.
2. Reduced expenditures to achieve a balanced budget, and thus, to still fears deterring business expansion.
3. An end to coercion and violence in relations between capital and labor.
4. Opposition to “unnecessary” government competition with private enterprise.
5. Recognition that private investment and enterprise require a reasonable profit.
6. Safeguarding the collateral upon which credit rests.
7. Reduction of taxes, or if this proved impossible at the moment, firm assurance of no further increases.
8. Maintenance of state rights, home rule, and local self-government, except where proved definitely inadequate.
9. Economical and non-political relief to unemployed with maximum local responsibility.
10. Reliance upon the American form of government and the American system of enterprise.

The effect this had on the nation’s recovery can of course never be known, as the war intervened just a few years later, but this laid a foundation that governed the post war conservative boom years. Also, sounds strikingly like the “Contract With America”, doesn’t it?  Newt et al used it as a guideline.

 

If I’m to be condemned to wearing the red RINO “R” of shame because I voted AGAINST Obama, so be it. I still maintain that, having done all we can in the primaries to nominate solid conservatives (as I have just done, successfully!) if it gets down to a RINO vs MARXIST in the general election: An electable RINO is preferable to an unelectable conservative. And it’s time to toss some water on this conservative family feud. IMHO

Monday, May 24, 2010

BURN: Sometimes Judge Napolitano Is Nuts

Generally, I like and admire Judge Andrew Napolitano.  Generally, I like and admire John Stossel.  But sometimes Libertarians seem hell-bent on making themselves politically impotent by saying stuff that is just nuts.

I've said and written for decades that Libertarians have all the practical political power of a Star Trek convention.  There are great reasons for that, as displayed very nicely on last week's Stossel program on Fox.


Judge Napolitano held forth for the proposition that kiddie porn is protected free speech under the First Amendment...sort of.  He said that consuming kiddie porn is protected, and is nobody's business, but that producing kiddie porn is bad and should be proscribed.  That is nuts, and for various reasons.

He also said something to the effect that outlawing kiddie porn was  a species of prohibition, and we all know how well that works...wink, wink.  Stossel's studio audience seemed to warmly agree.

But the reality is that prohibition works fine way more often than it does not.  Napolitano either does not know that, or he was being disingenuous.  Either way, his position is completely irrational.

We prohibit murder, theft, reckless driving...any number of things.  We do that very successfully, which is not to say that these things are never done.  Only that they are very successful examples of prohibition working.

Don't care for those examples?  How about our prohibition of private possession of high explosives?  How about our prohibition of highly radioactive material in private hands?  Or pathogens?

As I asserted, prohibition works more often...by far...than it fails to work.  And it does fail to work, and often spectacularly.  Why?  Because the scheme of prohibition is not popularly supported.  When it is supported popularly, prohibition works very well.

So Napolitano is just talking nonsense when he asserts that prohibition is a bad idea.

He's also ignoring economic basics when he suggests that you can have a demand for something (i.e., kiddie porn), while prohibiting supply.  That is simply wrong.  If you allow the demand to go without proscription, you WILL have someone moving to provide whatever people are demanding.  That is a certainty.

An example is criminalizing prostitutes, while letting their johns go without penalty.  It is silly and wrong.

I also take violent exception to the Stossel theme that the First Amendment covers...or should cover...the exchange of any kind of idea.  Kiddie porn is a great example of ideation that society has a real, obvious and totally constitutional interest in suppressing.

Which leads us to another of Yurhonor's fallacious statements: if there is some disparate standard of law in one community than another, that is unconstitutional (i.e., as in obscenity law).  Bullspit!  We call that Federalism.  This is a favorite canard among SOME libertarian thinkers.  They point to the horror of Blue Laws, which I agree are dumb.  But I also support the idea of local people expressing even dumb notions in law, so long as I have the option of removing myself to a different locale if I find those laws sufficiently onerous.  We want that in America. The alternative is totalitarianism, where we have a homogenized law that falls on us all, regardless of our values and standards.



In some jurisdictions, killing a litter of kittens or puppies (unless you are the authorities) is considered a crime.  In vast swaths of the American hinterland, it is considered responsible stewardship.  Farmers and ranchers live much more reality-driven lives, and we don't have "authorities" to whom we delegate unpleasant tasks that nature insists somebody perform.  If some urbanite finds it anathema that kittens should be killed (outside the local animal shelter), I can live with that.  So can the Constitution.

Like a lot of conservatives, I share a lot of common cause with libertarians.  I have trouble when their ideology leaves the realm of reason, which sometimes they allow it to do.  See Rand Paul...

Friday, May 21, 2010

THE HUMANITY: What We Conservatives Conserve

We are all asked what it is we conservatives are conserving.  Our answers are sometimes quite different, one from another.  Sometimes, we are told what we think by people who do not know us, some of whom do not like  us or wish us well.  We should know what we think and believe, and we should be able to express it well to others.  So the question of conserving what? is important.

I have been chewing on the "What do you conservatives conserve" question for years, and with some success.  I knew what I believed, and what I value.  But the problem is in framing it so that others understand.  For instance, when I ask a lot of people what it is they want to conserve, they say, "The American Way Of Life".  

Well, that can work for us, if we have a clear common understanding of what that is.  Trouble is, we don't, I'm afraid.  I don't think my vision of the American way of life has a lot in common with Barack Hussain Obama's version, or that of Bill Ayers, or Jeremiah Wright.  Or sometimes Joe Dokes or John Doe.

But I think I found something that I can say I conserve, and maybe it has a lot in common with what it is you conserve.

A lot has been written lately in connection with the trend in our society to accommodate Islamist extremist views.  It should be the subject of a lot of writing, thinking, and acting.  My thinking solidified around something...a cri de guerre...Mark Goldblat wrote in Reason on the subject.  “You want to kill the Enlightenment, you’re going to have to come through me.”


That was it.  That is what I'm conserving.  I am conserving the Enlightenment.  And maybe that doesn't seem like the holy grail of slick communication to you.  I mean, do we have a common understanding...or common enough understanding...of what the Enlightenment means for that to be a great focus for thought?  Is the Enlightenment really great as our brand?

I'm not sure I know the answer to that one, but I think it either is pretty universal, or we should make it so.  For certain, that would be no bad thing to work at.  What was...is...the Enlightenment?

Well, let me disclaim quickly any pretense at scholarship or particular knowledge on the subject.  I'm just a guy, a country lawyer who's done a lot of things in life, and read some stuff.  So what I say here is prone to well-founded criticism by people who may know a lot more, but here goes; the Enlightenment was a process of bringing humanity out of the long night of the Middle Ages.  It depended on reason, and the development...or redevelopment or re-imposition...of rational thinking, leading to modern science.  It depended on the development of systems of laws and equity...occurring on very different tracks...that eventually were merged into modern legal systems.  It depended on a vision of man that realized certain verities...what we call human nature...that are constant, predictable, and general across our race.  It held eventually that each man and each woman held potential, and that their potential could be used well or badly, as they individually chose to use it.  Eventually, the Enlightenment brought humanity the system of cooperation, effort, communication, failure and reward that we call today capitalism.  Eventually, it led to a totally new, unheard of set of ideals that were worked out, with considerable trial and error, into what we know as the Constitution and its Bill Of Rights.

Of course, there is a lot more to it than that.  We'll kick this around some more...

What did all that do, really?  Well, for my ancestors and yours, having a chair to sit on was considered high living.  Having the right to hold that chair against the demand of a noble was unheard of.  If you got a chair, you would loose a chair if they wanted it, and there was nothing wrong with that; nothing you could do about it.  We lived in the dark mostly, we died young, our children died in infancy, we saw little of the world, were mostly always uncomfortable, we were pretty much afraid of everything we didn't understand...which was everything, we were hungry a lot, sick a lot, and exhausted a lot.  If, in the process of living that dark, harsh life, we had a thought...or wanted to get one...we had a problem; thoughts were hard to come by and hard to express.  Books were precious things, few in number, and an impenetrable mystery to most of humanity, who did not read.  Plus, if that thought of yours offended somebody, they could silence it...and you.

So, put me down in the pro-Enlightenment column.  I want to preserve that stuff that millions of people worked out for us, for our benefit in this time.  I want to conserve the zenith of human existence on this planet, and not surrender it to another Dark Age...no matter who it is that's working to impose it on me and mine, or you and yours.

Monday, May 17, 2010

CRASH: Yes, Deemocrats, There IS A Constitutional Role In The Gulf

For about a week, I've been hearing idiot Deemocrats chant the collectivist talking-point suggesting that conservatives are hypocritical for expecting the Feds to act in the Gulf Of Mexico.  "Where in the Constitution do you find that, hmmmm....?"


Well, what that supposedly killer question illuminates is the overwhelming constitutional ignorance of collectivists, not any hypocrisy on the part of conservatives.

The Gulf situation is a pure example of APPROPRIATE Commerce Clause action by the Federal government.  Duh.

Where you have a situation that LEGITIMATELY impacts commercial activity ACROSS several states, you have a LEGITIMATE argument for Federal intervention.


Where you have a situation LEGITIMATELY effecting the navigable waters of the United States, you have an ADMIRALTY law situation, which is fundamentally FEDERAL.  It is ALSO manifestly a COMMERCE CLAUSE issue effecting all states on a practical level, quite apart from legalism.

So, Deemocrats, you see that there ARE appropriate, constitutional areas of FEDERAL activity that conservatives understand and support.  Not too surprising that you guys don't have a freaking clue, though.