Pages

Showing posts with label Commerce Clause. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Commerce Clause. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 23, 2011

BURN: The Deliberate Madness Of The Courts, Pt 1

Normal people can read where our Constitution says Congress has power "To regulate commerce with foreign nations, and among the several states, and with the Indian tribes".  After reading those plain words, normal people understand what they say.  But the very deliberate people who sit on our courts cannot read those words and understand them.  They are deliberately mad.

For anyone of average intelligence and understanding "interstate commerce" is distinguished from "intrastate commerce".  This distinction was a great big "wull, duh" that you will see for about 150 years in American Commerce Clause jurisprudence.  Commerce "among the states" (INTERstate commerce) was the kind of commerce the Constitution permitted Congress to regulate.

There were excellent reasons for that EXPRESS reservation, and for the power being granted to Congress in the first place.  Consider who was meeting at the Constitutional Congress, and what experience had brought them there.


These were REPRESENTATIVES from sovereign states...mini-nations.  They were meeting to CONSIDER a replacement for the Articles Of Confederation, which had kind of been a flop.  The CONSTITUTION they were playing around with was an EXPERIMENT...another turn at the governmental bat, and they did not...some of them...even believe it would work out.  Their first royalty was to their individual state.

One of the BIG failures of the Articles Of Confederation was in the area of commerce between these mini-nations.  It had been quite ugly, actually.  The states put tariffs on stuff moving through them to other states, there was huge disparity between a state citizen and an "alien" from another state in the courts, and there was even some barrier to travel between the states, not the least of which was just having roads.  I could go on at length, but clearly, this would not do.


So, INTERstate commerce was a VERY BIG reason there was a Constitutional Convention.  But, remember who was there...representatives from mini-nations...who were TRYING a new EXPERIMENT.  These people were not about to give away the farm to the untried experiment.  HELL NO!  They were very jealous of their own mini-nation's rights.  There was no need...and certainly no intent by the Founders...for the newly formed Congress to have power to regulate INTRAstate commerce.  That belonged to the individual states, and they WANTED it that way.  That is why they WROTE it that way.

Somehow...and we'll discuss that in a future post...this idea of making commerce possible and productive and fair when conducted between the states has been perverted.  It has been perverted now to the point where a judge can deliberate a question under this simple clause, and come up with shear madness.

Saturday, June 12, 2010

CRASH: Obama Opens The Barn Door For Conservatives

In one of his patented blame-fests, Barack Hussain Obama's usual misrepresentations of his opponents opened the barn door for you and I to show our neighbors just what our philosophy of government really is, and why they should support it.


His self-excusing, intentional distortion talking points weren't even original.  In fact, we've dealt with them here...weeks ago.  He's what he said:
“I think it’s fair to say, if six months ago, before this spill had happened, I had gone up to Congress and I had said we need to crack down a lot harder on oil companies and we need to spend more money on technology to respond in case of a catastrophic spill, there are folks up there, who will not be named, who would have said this is classic, big-government overregulation and wasteful spending.”
But the funny thing is, Mr. President, a lot of those people passed a law back in 1994...the National Oil And Hazardous Substances Contingency Plan Act...that MANDATED--(h/t Climate Audit)
  1. a plan for dealing with various scenarios around oil and hazardous substances
  2. testing that plan to assure it worked
  3. effective response to a large oil spill was a national priority that could overwhelm regional resources
  4. the EPA and the Coast Guard are in charge of the plan and its testing and implementation
So, it is instructive, isn't it Mr. Obama?  We already have a law, and clearly defined Federal lines of responsibility (consistent with the Commerce Clause, BTW) that MANDATED you have a response "in case of a catastrophic spill".  The crazy lady you picked for your EPA chief?  Where is she?  Isn't she, or somebody she names, supposed to be the chair of the National Response Team?  You know, the one in charge of making the plan YOU are supposed to have work.  She has been in the news lately, but it isn't because of her work along the Gulf coast, is it, Mr. President?


That National Response Team, you hear of them all the time, right?  Hmmm....  Me neither.  It's like they just lost track of the whole idea they were supposed to have a National Response Team, and a plan, and technology in place, and drills testing the plan, and stuff.  What's that old saying about trying to do too much...?  And isn't there one about a government governs best when it governs least? 
“Some of the same folks who have been hollering and saying ‘do something’ are the same folks who, just two or three months ago, were suggesting that government needs to stop doing so much,” Obama said. “Some of the same people who are saying the president needs to show leadership and solve this problem are some of the same folks who, just a few months ago, were saying this guy is trying to engineer a takeover of our society through the federal government that is going to restrict our freedoms.”
And, of course, this is where Obama erects his second favorite person in the world...Mr. Straw Man.  No TEA Party activist or conservative whats NO government.  What we want is LIMITED government.  Why?  Well, golly there are so many reasons, but one of them is that we understand that LIMITED government is also EFFECTIVE at doing the few things it is chartered to do.  And we all want EFFECTIVE government.

So, this is one of those sterling moments...a teachable moment...when you can share with your neighbors why you believe what you do about the incredible wisdom of the design of our Constitution, providing for a limited, effective government.

Monday, May 17, 2010

CRASH: Yes, Deemocrats, There IS A Constitutional Role In The Gulf

For about a week, I've been hearing idiot Deemocrats chant the collectivist talking-point suggesting that conservatives are hypocritical for expecting the Feds to act in the Gulf Of Mexico.  "Where in the Constitution do you find that, hmmmm....?"


Well, what that supposedly killer question illuminates is the overwhelming constitutional ignorance of collectivists, not any hypocrisy on the part of conservatives.

The Gulf situation is a pure example of APPROPRIATE Commerce Clause action by the Federal government.  Duh.

Where you have a situation that LEGITIMATELY impacts commercial activity ACROSS several states, you have a LEGITIMATE argument for Federal intervention.


Where you have a situation LEGITIMATELY effecting the navigable waters of the United States, you have an ADMIRALTY law situation, which is fundamentally FEDERAL.  It is ALSO manifestly a COMMERCE CLAUSE issue effecting all states on a practical level, quite apart from legalism.

So, Deemocrats, you see that there ARE appropriate, constitutional areas of FEDERAL activity that conservatives understand and support.  Not too surprising that you guys don't have a freaking clue, though.