Pages

Showing posts with label Cordoba House. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cordoba House. Show all posts

Sunday, September 12, 2010

THE HUMANITY: On Dhimmitude And Incitement

It has been an interesting weekend, in the fullest sense.  Like millions of Americans, I commemorated the ninth anniversary of 9/11.  Like many...I hope most...of those Americans, I experienced a mixture of sorrow, anger, loathing, and shame as I considered the Twin Towers, their demise, the act of Islamist murder, and the fiddling of the replacement at Ground Zero.


I also received an education.  To my surprise, there are people in America who support the burning of books, and defend the practice quite fiercely.  To my surprise, there are people in America who think that Muslims--

1. are a monolith

2. that universally seeks the imposition of Sharia (like there is A Sharia)

3. and that any appearance of assimilation or moderation (which they say they look for) is just a deception.

Some of these people make no bones about voicing the old, old, "The only good _____ is a dead _____" horror.

Please understand, I do not suggest there are a lot of these kinds of people in America.  Merely that there are these people, and they are not the least backward about trumpeting their bigotry and medieval urges.

I have been called a "dhimmi" for the piece I wrote in which I state that burning books is un-American, and decidedly un-Christian.  As I said, an interesting weekend.

Here is why I am emphatically NOT a "dhimmi", while concurrently NOT in favor of burning books...or more to the point...Korans.

To me, there is the broad, readily defined avenue between living as one does in Western society (and damn the feelings of Islamic Rage-Boy), and doing something that is an affront to Western values (like burning a sacred book) for the sole purpose of inciting ANYBODY.


In American society, it is normal conduct (i.e., within the norms we accept) for people (generally rather nasty people) to lampoon or criticize religions in art or letters...even in very profane ways.  We have this whole First Amendment thingy that protects even scumbags who do that sort of thing.  So, I have NO problem publishing cartoons lampooning Mohamed, and DAMN the hypersensitivity of Islamic Rage-Boy--h/t Malkin).  It is what we do here in America; like listening to music, or shaving, or any number of other things some say are verboten.

That is fundamentally different than going out of my way...and out of American norms...to incite people.  That isn't, to me, an act of defiant living at all.  It is an act of rankest stupidity and meanness.

Think of it this way; I NEVER have been able to let a bully be a bully.  Something inside me always makes me fight (my teeth bear testimony).  And when I do, I know that a lot of people around me support me...largely because I have the moral high-ground.  Conversely, if I go out in the street and scream at the top of my lungs that the bully's sister is a profligate WHORE, nobody is going to support that.  And one more thing; I would know I was wrong to do it, and ought to get my ars stomped.


There are two kinds of Islamophobes in America...the first is afraid of what Islamists might do to them for merely living as Americans (like most supporters of the Cordoba House)...the second is afraid of Muslims period.  I am neither.  We are stronger than they.  We should live like that.

Friday, August 27, 2010

BURN: Another Mosquetteer Who Can't Say The "T" Word & Hamas

The estimable Andy McCarthy very nicely, civilly, corners another Imam apologist for the Cordoba House.  Listen CAREFULLY, and learn.




So, people, here's the take-away.  Even these "moderate" Muslim apologists cannot bring themselves, on national television, to identify a terrorist organization as terrorists.  How "moderate" IS that?  CAIR also claims to be "moderate", and they are no such thing.  They are not al Qaeda, but they are not harmless, either.

Does this imply that there are no Muslims who are actually moderate, peaceful, law-abiding people?  NEVER!!!  I know many.  But the lies and disinformation on the Cordoba House just keep coming, and the people behind it just look worse and worse.

Thursday, August 19, 2010

CRASH: The Mosquetteers Are Obvious Liars

I won't rehash here all that's been written on Cordoba House, or Ground Zero Mosque.  The bottom line for me is that the reasons for the mosque cum "cultural center" are manifest lies.  That is enough.

We WERE told (the story is mutating) that the Cordoba House was to be for "bridge-building" and "cultural exchange".  We now see that was never the purpose.

If that were your purpose for building something...anything...and you were met with a firestorm of opposition from people...the VERY people you claim to want to reach...who told you your project was an unwonted provocation and insult, what would you do? 

If you were offered meetings with the governor of the state, and the suggestion was made that another, less inflammatory site could be found with government help...and you purpose was REALLY to "build bridges"...what would you do?

Anyone with any integrity can answer those questions.  We all know the answer.  It requires no great leap of deductive logic to know, then, that the purpose given was a lie.

We've been told that by other Muslims:
The fact [is] we Muslims know the idea behind the Ground Zero mosque is meant to be a deliberate provocation to thumb our noses at the infidel. The proposal has been made in bad faith and in Islamic parlance, such an act is referred to as "Fitna," meaning "mischief-making" that is clearly forbidden in the Koran.
And what of the liars who told their lies?  Victor Davis Hanson helps--
Then we come to Imam Rauf himself. To his liberal defenders, he is a sort of respectable Deepak Chopra who at respectable places like Aspen mouths pop platitudes of interfaith tolerance — so much so that our own State Department has employed him, apparently for quite some time, for goodwill gallivanting abroad. 
But to those in the Middle East, he is known equally well for doing what he can, as a Western liberal, to contextualize terrorism, bin Laden, and Islamic extremism within the tired Western postmodern tropes of cultural relativism: “The United States’ policies were an accessory to the crime that happened” on 9/11; “In fact, in the most direct sense, Osama bin Laden is made in the U.S.A.”; “The U.S. and the West must acknowledge the harm they have done to Muslims before terrorism can end”; “The issue of terrorism is a very complex question”; “The Islamic method of waging war is not to kill innocent civilians. But it was Christians in World War II who bombed civilians in Dresden and Hiroshima, neither of which were military targets” — blah, blah, blah, like all the thinkery that one hears in the faculty lounge.
I have heard the man daintily demur to label Hamas as the terrorists they certainly are.  That is a level of "moderation" that makes the man positively dangerous...and, again, a liar.

His Cordoba House, not being what he pretends it would be, would be...what?
Abroad, the message would, of course, be interpreted quite differently: To the radical Islamists, a mosque rising near Ground Zero well before a new World Trade Center is constructed is a message of Islamic triumphalism — in the long tradition of minarets on the conquered Santa Sophia in Istanbul, the eighth-century Al-Aqsa mosque in Jerusalem rising on the site of the destroyed Jewish Second Temple, and the great mosque at Cordoba retrofitted from the gutted Christian Church of St. Vincent. Again, there are thousands of sites in New York where another mosque could be built; but without the Ground Zero resonance, the irony would be lost. 
Then we come to the funding of the supposed $100 million, 13-story Islamic center (“mosque” has become a right-wing defamation for a complex devoted to contemplation and meditation). Mr. Rauf is not engaged in a nationwide fundraising drive of the sort Americans are used to for preserving iconic ships or refurbishing the Statue of Liberty. Instead, he is apparently counting on petrodollars from the Middle East. Given the authoritarian, and religiously intolerant, regimes in most of the Gulf sheikdoms, one can assume that donations will not be predicated on Imam Rauf’s supposed efforts at an Islamic Reformation. Otherwise, what better place to start than Saudi Arabia? 
The mutating story has now become the canard that this is a much-needed place of worship for a growing Muslim population, under-served by existing mosques.  Bull.  Everyone with a brain knows what this is, and that "a simple place of worship" could be anywhere.  But for the promoters of this Islamist Arch 'd Triumph, nowhere else will do.

I do not object to a mosque in the Lower East Side.  Actually, I'd welcome it, if that is all it is.  What I object to is an Islamist operational headquarters and iconic monument being built within sight of the place where victims' remains are today being pulled out of the rubble of the Twin Towers.

Sunday, August 15, 2010

THE HUMANITY: Remembering FDR's Historic Shinto Shrine Speech

We all remember the historic day that FDR, while hosting a Shinto ceremony in the White House during WWII, reminded Americans that everyone had a right to worship as they chose.  Right...?

Of course we don't remember that act of political suicide, because it never happened.  No one in America would have dreamed of such a thing as we were engaged in a war with not just a people but a warped religious ideology that had brought flame and death to our home in an unprovoked attack.


Of course, in that day, no Japanese-American would have suggested they could, would, or should build a Shinto shrine a block or two from the smoking hulk of the U.S.S. Arizona even as divers sought remains of the dead aboard her.  That would have been an unthinkable affront.

The Shinto religion held that the Emperor was a literal god on earth.  No believer would dare doubt the Emperor, or his appointed minions.  Under the Emperor, Japan had undertaken to assert what the Shinto martial cult had decreed was its destiny.  They did it aggressively via a war of merciless expansion.  It was much more than a religion; it was an integrated socio-political construct that operated according to its own norms.  Those norms were at existential swords-point with Western norms.

During WWII, this was a known reality that shaped everything done by the U.S. and its allies, from the common combat soldier to the leaders of state.  But that was before the modern cult of moral relativity gained a foot-hold in American life...before we began to loath our own virtue and see atrocity as a merely "another, equally valid truth".

In WWII, a Shinto follower of the Emperor who espoused the beliefs of the martial cult in Japan...regardless of his citizenship...would have been changed, tried and imprisoned.  Sadly and shamefully, many loyal Japanese-Americans who did not follow the Emperor were put in concentration camps and their property taken.  We were better than that then, and we are today.

In America today, we are confused.  Do Muslim Americans have a right to build their mosques?  Of course, and they do.  Few would dream of denying them that right.  To the extent that they have, they have been marginalized as they should.


But what of the Islamists...that martial, expansionist element of Islam that actively seeks...today...to destroy Western pluralism?  Do they have a right to build, to preach, to recruit?  Do they have a right to build the equivalent of a Shinto shrine on the Pearl Harbor water-front, even while the remains of the 9/11 dead are still being recovered?  Our WWII generation would have been amazed at the question.

Most of America is still amazed...and angered...that anyone would pose that question.  What angers them more is the inference or declaration that opposition to the Cordoba House is the result of bigotry against all Muslims.  That, they know, is simply a lie, and they resent the lie.  They are not confused about the propriety of the Cordoba House, or the intent of its promoters.